Secondary sales: liquidity before an exit.

A secondary sale lets you sell your startup shares to another investor while the company stays private - cash years before an acquisition or a float, if a buyer and a price can be found.

Most angel money is locked up for the best part of a decade. You wire the cheque, the company gets on with the long, uncertain business of building something, and your stake sits there as a number on a statement until an acquisition or a float finally turns it into cash. A secondary sale is how some angels get out before then - by selling their existing shares to another investor while the company carries on, privately, exactly as before.

So let's be precise about what changes hands. In a secondary, no new shares are created and not a penny reaches the company's bank account. Your shares move from your name to the buyer's; the proceeds go to you. That's the whole difference between a secondary and the rounds angels are used to - and it's the difference that shapes everything else about how these deals work.

Secondary versus primary: what's actually different?

A primary transaction is the funding round you already know. The company issues brand-new shares, an investor pays for them, and the cash lands on the company's balance sheet to fund hiring, product, growth. The investor's stake is created out of thin air, and everyone else is diluted a little to make room for it.

A secondary creates nothing. An existing shareholder - an angel, a founder, an early employee - sells the shares they already own to a buyer. No dilution, no new capital, no change to the cap table's size; just a name swapped on the register. The company is often a bystander to its own shareholders' transaction, though, as we'll see, it rarely stays entirely out of the way.

A primary funds the company. A secondary funds the shareholder. Same shares, completely different transaction.

When do secondaries happen?

The most common moment is alongside a later primary round. When a growth-stage fund leads a Series B or C, it sometimes wants a larger position than the new shares alone would give it, and offers to buy some early stock as part of the deal. That suits everyone: the fund gets its ownership, and the first angels and founders get to take some money off the table after years of paper gains. These bundled secondaries are where most angel liquidity-before-exit actually comes from.

Beyond that, a few other channels exist. There are dedicated secondary buyers and funds that exist specifically to acquire private shares. There are platforms that try to match holders of early-stage stock with willing buyers. And occasionally a company runs a formal tender, inviting shareholders to sell a set portion of their holdings at an agreed price - a tidy, sanctioned way to give early backers liquidity without a full exit. What unites all of them is the same hard constraint: a secondary only exists when someone wants to buy.

How are secondary shares priced?

This is where private markets stop behaving like the public ones. A listed share has a price every second of the trading day. A private share has no price at all until two people agree one, and the obvious reference point - the last funding round's valuation - is a flattering starting figure rather than a clearing price.

Buyers of secondary stock discount it, and for sound reasons. The shares are illiquid; the buyer may get limited information rights; early-stage companies fail far more often than they exit; and the seller, by definition, is the one who wants out. Put those together and a discount of 20 to 40 percent off the last round is unremarkable, with wider gaps for very early stock or a company whose recent trajectory has wobbled. The headline valuation makes a good anchor and a poor promise. Whatever you're quoted, the cheque that actually clears is the number that counts.

Why you can't just sell whenever you like

Plenty of first-time angels assume their shares are theirs to sell as they please. They usually aren't - not without permission. The company's articles and the shareholder agreement almost always carry transfer restrictions designed to keep founders in control of who ends up on the register.

Three clauses do most of the work. Pre-emption rights often require you to offer your shares to existing shareholders before any outsider, at the same price. A right of first refusal lets the company or its backers step in and match a buyer you've already lined up. Board consent provisions can simply require sign-off on any transfer. None of these necessarily blocks a sale, but they shape it, slow it, and can hand your carefully negotiated buyer straight to someone with a prior claim. Read the transfer provisions before you treat a secondary as done - they're the terms that decide whether the sale is even yours to make.

What happens to SEIS and EIS relief in a secondary?

For UK angels, this is the part most likely to turn a good price into a bad outcome. The venture schemes reward patience, and a secondary is, by its nature, an early exit.

Both SEIS and EIS carry a minimum holding period of three years. Sell your shares before that, and the income tax relief you claimed - 50 percent of the investment for SEIS, 30 percent for EIS - can be withdrawn by HMRC. The capital gains exemption is also conditional: gains on SEIS and EIS shares are generally free of capital gains tax only where you've held them for at least three years and received income tax relief. A secondary that completes inside that window can therefore claw back the relief you banked and put the gain into charge - a double cost that can swamp the discount you accepted to sell early in the first place.

There's a quieter point for the buyer, too: shares bought second-hand don't come with fresh SEIS or EIS relief. The schemes apply to newly issued shares subscribed for in cash, not to stock acquired from another investor. A secondary buyer is buying the company's prospects, not a tax benefit.

The reliefs, holding periods and company-side rules do change, and several thresholds were revised in April 2026. Check the current position on the official guidance before acting: gov.uk's venture capital schemes guidance for investors. None of this is tax or investment advice - it's general information, and you should take FCA-regulated advice on your own circumstances before acting.

The honest version

Secondaries get talked up as the answer to angel investing's oldest frustration - the decade-long wait for money you can actually use. They can be exactly that. But the reality is narrower than the pitch. A secondary needs a willing buyer, an agreed price, the company's cooperation on transfer, and timing that doesn't trip your tax position. Line all four up and you have early liquidity on real terms. Miss one and you have a deal that either doesn't happen or costs more than it returns. They're a useful tool in a spread portfolio, not a way to undo the fact that early-stage investing is, at heart, a long game.

Subscribe

Get The Carry every Wednesday.

Free. One email a week. About six minutes. Read by 60+ active UK angel investors.

Free · 6-minute read · Every Wednesday

One-click unsubscribe. We never sell subscriber data.

Frequently asked questions

What is a secondary sale?

A secondary sale is the sale of existing shares from one investor to another while the company stays private. No new money goes into the business - the shares simply change hands. It gives early shareholders such as angels and founders partial or full liquidity years before the company is acquired or floats.

How is a secondary sale different from a primary round?

In a primary round the company issues new shares and the cash goes onto its balance sheet to fund the business. In a secondary, no new shares are created and no money reaches the company - an existing shareholder sells their stake and keeps the proceeds. The two often happen at the same time, but they are separate transactions.

How are secondary shares priced?

There is no market price for private shares, so a secondary price is negotiated between buyer and seller. It usually references the last funding round's valuation, then applies a discount to reflect illiquidity, the buyer's risk, and the lack of information rights. Discounts of 20 to 40 percent off the last round are common, and can be larger for very early-stage stock.

Can I sell my startup shares whenever I want?

Usually not freely. Most shareholder agreements and company articles contain pre-emption rights, rights of first refusal, and board-consent clauses that control who you can sell to and on what terms. Existing shareholders often have the right to buy your shares first. Read the transfer provisions before you assume a sale is yours to make.

What happens to my SEIS or EIS relief if I sell in a secondary?

Selling SEIS or EIS shares before the three-year minimum holding period can cause the income tax relief you claimed to be withdrawn, and the capital gains exemption is generally only available once you have held the shares for at least three years with income tax relief received. A secondary that lands before that point can therefore be expensive after tax. This is general information, not advice - check the current rules on gov.uk and take regulated advice on your own position.

Share

More from The Carry

Related reads.

All Essentials →